Reform’s Reckoning: Judgement Day for Starmer and Labour

Britain heads to the polls today, in what promises to be one of the most consequential sets of elections in a generation. Across England’s council chambers, Scotland’s Holyrood and Wales’s Senedd, the ballot boxes are likely to deliver a verdict that the comfortable sofas at Westminster have long tried to ignore: Keir Starmer’s Labour government is in freefall. The Red Wall has crumbled for good. And far from capitalising as usual, the Conservative side of the Uniparty is odds-on for a thrashing too. 

The cause? Parliament after parliament promised “change”, but delivered more of the same. Ordinary, working-class Brits were forced to watch, powerless, as their towns were hollowed out, their wages squeezed by net-zero dogma and mass migration, and their streets made less safe by two-tier policing and cultural surrender. Before a single vote is cast, the direction of travel for the country is now crystal clear – a decisive shift away from the failed centrist consensus, towards a politics that actually puts Britain and the British people first. Nigel Farage’s Reform UK is not merely knocking on the door, it is kicking it down. 

Starmer meanwhile, already the most unpopular Prime Minister in living memory, faces a humiliation that will echo through the ages.

Defending just over half of the 5,000-odd council seats up for grabs, Labour is on course for a massacre. Poll trackers suggest Starmer’s party will lose anywhere from 1,400 to 1,900 seats. The Tories, still suffering from a bad case of political rigor mortis, are expected to shed another 800–900. The main beneficiaries? The Liberal Democrats, the Greens, and above all, Reform UK.

The latest YouGov numbers tell their own grim story: Labour has slumped to 18%, virtually tied with the Tories on 17%, while Reform sits comfortably out in front on 25%. Independent psephologists Stephen Fisher and Sir John Curtice both forecast that Reform could sweep between 1,300 and 2,260 seats (easily within my long-standing forecast of 1,500–2,000 gains, as regular TNC readers will know). That would mean Reform taking control of multiple Red Wall heartlands: Sunderland, Wakefield, Barnsley, Wigan and beyond, while potentially flipping eastern counties such as Essex, Norfolk and Suffolk from the Conservatives. The working-class revolt that delivered Brexit is not just continuing, it is completing its journey.

North of the border, the picture is equally damning for Labour. YouGov’s MRP modelling for the Scottish Parliament election shows the SNP heading for a narrow majority (around 67 seats), but Reform UK, polling neck-and-neck with or ahead of Labour on both constituency and list votes, is set for a historic breakthrough of roughly 20 MSPs. Labour, once the undisputed master of Scotland, is collapsing into a pathetic rump of perhaps 15 seats, scrapping with the Greens and Lib Dems for third place. Reform isn’t just overtaking Labour – it is replacing it as the real opposition to the SNP.

South of the border in Wales, the story is similar but even more dramatic. Recent YouGov MRP modelling for ITV Cymru Wales puts Reform and Plaid Cymru in a dead heat for first place, with Labour a humiliating third on around 12-16%. While an outright “win” for Reform in Wales remains a tight call (Plaid currently edges it in some models), the party is on course for 34-37 seats and the effective destruction of Welsh Labour’s century-long stranglehold. Only the most Panglossian Labour loyalist could pretend this is anything other than total humiliation.

London, as ever, is the partial outlier that proves the rule. Reform may well make solid inroads in the outer boroughs like Bexley, Havering, Bromley, but the inner city will remain impregnable. Instead, the capital looks set to fracture further, with the Greens surging as the Muslim vote deserts Labour en masse over Gaza and foreign policy. 

Far be it from an imbecile like me to question the sagacity of Sir John Curtice, but I must diverge slightly from his analysis here. In short, I think the scale of Labour’s annihilation and consequentially Reform’s success are being slightly underestimated. 

Here’s why:

1. While ‘shy Tories’ were once a thing, and one certainly wouldn’t claim Reform UK supporters are ‘shy’ to the same degree, there is a consistent shy voter effect that pollsters have repeatedly failed to capture in terms of Reform. 
2. The disenchantment with Labour and the entire Uniparty duopoly is now truly nationwide, in a way we have never seen before. Even The Guardian concedes, this could deliver “unprecedented” losses for a governing party. 
3. That being the case, and noting the propensity of the British public to give the incumbent administration a kicking in the locals, 2026 is genuinely going to prove the battle of the protest vote. On the right, voters will flock to Reform because they want an end to uncontrolled immigration and the Islamisation of Britain. On the left, voters will embrace the Greens because they feel uncontrolled immigration and Islamisation haven’t gone far enough! 
4. The shine may well have come off Zack Polanski, now that he has been subject to heightened scrutiny. The Green Party leader has been roundly criticised for previously ‘liking’ antisemitic Facebook posts, claiming that British Jews might be experiencing a “perception of unsafety”, and recent revelations that he lied on his CV about being a spokesman for the British Red Cross. Having said that, many Green Party voters may see this as a measure of Polanski’s ‘soundness’. 
5. In terms of the Tories, the ‘Kemi bounce’ has been undeniable, with her current favourability sitting at -23, her highest figure since becoming leader. However, this has failed to filter through to her party, which remains as unpopular as ever.  

The political fallout from such a night will be seismic. Starmer will cling on for now of course (the man has no shame), but the scale of the defeat will render his position untenable, meaning a leadership contest will now have no more excuses to stall. Indeed, the knives are already out for Starmer, with the hapless runners and riders already firmly on manoeuvres. Angela Rayner has reportedly quit vaping (a heroic sacrifice, although HMRC is unlikely to be impressed at the loss of tax revenue), Wes Streeting is busy practising his concerned frown in the mirror, and Andy Burnham sits in Manchester still praying he can be parachuted into a “safe” Labour seat. Good luck with that, Andy. At this rate, they’ll be holding the leadership election in a phone box.

There is a certain dark satisfaction that only pure schadenfreude can bring. But no matter how enjoyable Labour’s destruction, the country is still left picking up the tab. The real bright spot come Friday morning will be this: Reform UK can no longer be classified as a mere insurgency – it is a serious political force. Whoever emerges from Labour’s inevitable bloodbath will almost certainly be just as useless as Starmer (though Angela Rayner may at least provide better entertainment). And that, ladies and gentlemen, makes an early general election not just likely, but increasingly inevitable.

Frank Haviland is the author of Banalysis: The Lie Destroying the West and The Frank Report Substack.

If you enjoy The New Conservative and would like to support our work, please consider buying us a coffee – it would really help to keep us going. Thank you!

Please follow and like us: